They call them “sidewalk Indians” or “apples”—red outside, white within—as though identity could be measured by language fluency or the number of beads on a necklace. This dismissal cuts deeper than any slur, pushing some to code-switch so perfectly that even their grandmothers raise an eyebrow. Yet those same “apples” host open-mic nights where spoken-word poets riff on reservation memory, where hip-hop beats pulse alongside drum circles until dawn. In a century-old church repurposed as a grassroots clinic, healers offer sweat-lodge ceremonies in the basement and free health services upstairs, speaking in English and native tongues like threads in the same tapestry [5].

Hope pulses strongest at the annual Big Oakland Powwow. It’s a day when twelve urban voices—from a Dene storyteller determined to preserve family legends to a Lakota teen facing addiction—converge in a dance of resilience. Beneath the freeway overpasses, I’ve watched grandchildren learn drum songs from grandparents who refuse to let highways drown out centuries of memory. In that dusty circle, loss and renewal collide, and every step is a defiant promise: culture can thrive anywhere, even on sidewalks cracked by indifferent city planners [2]. Outside, the skyline gleams; inside, the heartbeat of community refuses to fade.

Twelve Distinct Voices Woven Together

Tommy Orange’s novel stitches its narrative with twelve unique urban Native perspectives, each chapter a thread in a tapestry that unfolds across Oakland’s streets and into the dusty arena of the Big Oakland Powwow. There’s Dene Oxendene, grieving his uncle’s lost stories yet determined to tell them through his documentary project; Orvil Red Feather, teaching himself dance steps from YouTube tutorials in a studio apartment; and Edwin Black, desperately hunting for his registration papers amid bureaucratic indifference. Through these voices, readers experience the bitter clash of assimilation and ancestral pull—the “hurtling quality” that hurtles every character toward a shared reckoning [1] and the fragile heartbeat of identity.

Each portrait feels intimate and urgent. When Orvil admits, “I started dancing in front of the TV because no one taught me,” you can almost hear the TV static and feel the ache of roots just out of reach. Critics praise the structure as both mosaic and novel: chapters so concise they land like poems, yet bound together by shared history and the thrum of community drums [3]. Orange masterfully confronts stereotypes—“apples” and “sidewalk Indians”—but he also illuminates joy, from stolen smiles at powwow rehearsals to the camaraderie of a late-night powwow committee meeting under flickering streetlights [5].

What binds these stories isn’t just geography, but a collective insistence that remembrance matters. In the final convergence under the drum circle’s tent, characters find that despite trauma and displacement, they’re not alone. Their voices weave together, forming a chorus that refuses invisibility. That resonance—that raw, collective voice—is the heart of the novel, and the reason it reverberates long after the last page is turned.

Generational Trauma and the Strength of Tradition

The opening prologue of There There reads like a historical drumbeat, tracing centuries of violence, displacement, and broken treaties that echo through every family. Boarding schools stole language and laughter; treaties promised refuge yet delivered betrayal. Characters like Jacquie Red Feather carry this legacy in their bones, wrestling with grief as palpable as a clenched fist. Yet, for all the pain, tradition emerges as a healing tide. The Big Oakland Powwow, more than an event, becomes a lifeline where Orvil Red Feather finds his grandmother’s dance—and with it, a piece of his soul restored [1]. Even reviewers note how Orange balances “pulsing anger” with “tenderness,” making every ceremony feel both wounding and restorative [4].

Dene Oxendene channels familial loss into his film, capturing voices that might otherwise vanish. Tony Loneman grapples with inherited pain that warps reality into a fractured mirror—“I’m living in two worlds and both of them are a lie.” The novel doesn’t shy from shame or self-destruction; instead, it reveals how tradition—song, dance, language—offers a counterweight to trauma’s gravity. In one scene, elders teach drum songs beneath an overpass, the bass reverberating against concrete pillars, reminding young dancers that roots can grow through cracks [2]. And when those beats collide with modern bass lines at after-parties, you see resilience in motion: the power to transform silence into sound.

Through the intertwining of personal anguish and communal ritual, There There asserts that healing—and identity—aren’t solitary acts. They’re passed hand to hand, drumbeat to drumbeat, song to song, whispered around smoky circles or projected through a laptop speaker in a cramped apartment. It’s a map of survival drawn in footsteps across polished floors and cracked sidewalks alike.

Quest for Identity and Community

Oakland’s urban Native residents often navigate a silent tug-of-war between ancestral echoes and the ceaseless pull of city life. Labeled “citified” or “inauthentic,” they confront stereotypes that question their belonging. In the novel, Orvil’s younger brother Lony endures taunts at school, while Tony Loneman grapples with reality warped by fetal alcohol syndrome. Their parallel arcs—one seeking pride, the other teetering on despair—underscore Orange’s message: identity is both inherited and forged anew [5]. Against this backdrop, the Big Oakland Powwow shines like a beacon, a yearly chance to reclaim ceremony, language, and laughter in the face of erasure.

Key moments propel each character: Jacquie Red Feather’s return to sobriety, Edwin Black’s frantic search for lost registration papers, and Orvil’s midnight dance rehearsals in front of a grainy laptop screen—each step a rebellion, each choice a bid for self-definition [1]. The novel’s structure—short, punchy chapters—mirrors the fractured nature of urban Native lives, yet crescendos into a unifying drumbeat when all paths converge under the powwow tent [3]. It’s an electric moment where joy, sorrow, hope, and fear ricochet in every drum thump.

For readers wanting to explore these themes further, our detailed book review for first-time readers unpacks each character’s journey in context. And just as urban Natives find strength in community kitchens and powwow circles, so too does this novel stand as a testament to the power of collective storytelling—much like the unity felt at the Covenant Health Marathon, where community and spirit converge to uplift every runner’s heartbeat.

There There: The Final Tapestry of Resilience and Hope

In its closing chapters, There There weaves twelve threads into a powerful mosaic of modern Indigenous existence—raw, fractured, and beautifully persistent. Characters who began as isolated figures—Tony Loneman, clawing at inherited darkness; Orvil Red Feather, stitching identity from pixels; Jacquie Red Feather, rebuilding her life from addiction’s ashes—now stand side by side beneath the powwow’s grand tent. Their stories, once solitary beats, synchronize into a collective drum that reverberates through every reader’s chest [5].

This final convergence isn’t just narrative closure—it’s a living ceremony of survival. When the last drumbeat fades, you feel the weight of history and the lift of possibility intertwine. It’s a reminder that tradition isn’t static: it adapts, it migrates, it lives in stories shared around smoky fires or projected through YouTube tutorials in urban high-rises. Oddly enough, that mix of the old and the new—beadwork circles next to digital archives—becomes the novel’s most hopeful note. It tells us that resilience can find footing on cracked concrete, that voices once silenced can rise in unison, and that belonging is crafted every day, step by step, song by song.

Citations